About Us

• Underhill Insurance Agency, Inc. offers a full range of insurance products through a broad range of carrier companies. We have the ability to provide you with an amplitude of various products falling under the categories of Personal Insurance, Business & Commercial Insurance, individual and group Health & Life Insurance, and Travel Insurance. For a full listing of products, or to find out if we carry what you are looking for, please call our office. At Underhill Insurance Agency, we take pride in critical thinking, overcoming challenges, and developing an insurance program specific to your needs. Experience has enabled our multi-line agency to develop expertise in a broad spectrum of insurance. With this expertise we can help you to protect yourself from loss, which is why you buy insurance. We will help you analyze your exposure to risk and find insurance solutions to protect your assets. Your assets can include, homes, automobiles, recreational vehicles, commercial properties, businesses, savings and investments, health, life, earning potential, and identity, to name a few. Underhill Insurance Agency, Inc. was founded in April 1954 by Bob and Gladys Underhill. In 1976 ownership transferred to Chuck Underhill, and in 1982 his wife, Mary Underhill, joined the agency. In 2003 we added a third generation of family with the addition of our son, Richard Walker, and then again in 2014 when our daughter, Elizabeth Underhill, joined the agency. Some of our 2,500+ clients date back to the beginning of the agency. In April 2014, we celebrated our agency's 60th anniversary. As a way of saying thank you to all of our great customers who have kept us in business for so long, we introduced "Underhill Rewards". "Underhill Rewards" allows our clients to receive 1-40% cash back on online shopping purchases through an expansive variety of over 5,000 participating stores which provide over 3,000,000 products.