Welcome to Clayton’s Toys! Clayton’s Toys is Western New York’s one-stop toy shopping experience! Clayton’s Toys is an independently-owned toy store opened in Buffalo, New York in 1916. That’s over 100 years! At Clayton’s Toys you will find gifts, toys, games, novelties, and nostalgia for children of all ages! We have a vast selection of baby items, children’s books, dolls, stuffed animals and puppets, things to keep busy outside, science kits, art supplies, crafts, puzzles, building toys, trucks, and more!